INSURANCE –
08.19.13
Insurance is
shared risk. Because it is shared, it is
a win/win proposition. Insurance is
always protection against some undesirable event. If the event does not occur, you have
won, and you thank your lucky stars.
If the event occurs, you have financial help from those
lucky people who have escaped misfortune,
and you also have won.
But insurance is always a zero sum game; only some receive
the payoff, and that payoff is provided
by
those who have not received a payoff. It
should be obvious that insurance works best when everyone is in the pool. If only those who need it buy it, then those
who don’t need it don’t buy it. The
result has a name: self-insurance; it is, by definition, not insurance.
So
the best insurance is always mandatory.
There are three good reasons why single-payer health works so well. Everybody is in the pool, the pool has the
leverage necessary to squeeze the excess out of health provider prices, and the
middleman (the dreaded insurance company) is eliminated. Reference: Time Magazine, March 4, 2013.
ObamaCare
is what we get when Republicans will not accept single-payer, usually on the
grounds that it is “socialism”. They
would not even accept the “public option”.
Apparently they do not comprehend
the obvious fact that every collective purchase bought with taxes is
socialism. We do not need to question
the fact that single-payer is superior to fee-for-service. That trial over; the jury has considered the
arguments; the verdict has been rendered.
Most countries similar to the United States have a single-payer system, and not one has chosen
to switch from single-payer to fee-for-service.
For good reason: the averaged single-payer plan costs 52% of our
fee-for-service, and the quality of care is better by any valid criterion.
If
you don’t like ObamaCare, lobby hard for single-payer. Or for the next-best thing, the public
option.
Finally,
and as an addendum, we can hope for that one day, that bright and shining day,
when we become civilized, when people are allowed to control their lives. When life becomes too painful to bear, they
can opt out of their agony. Typically,
people spend as much on health in their last six months as they have in their
entire life up to that point. The
savings are obvious, but not determinable.
On that glorious day however, we will leading, and not dragging behind,
other like nations.
No comments:
Post a Comment